Reimagining Surveillance in the Age of Privacy: The Role of RISAA in Modern Cybersecurity

Reimagining Surveillance in the Age of Privacy: The Role of RISAA in Modern Cybersecurity
Photo by Adi Goldstein / Unsplash

In the evolving landscape of global cybersecurity, the interface between technology and legislation often becomes a pivotal point of focus. A prime example is the incorporation of RISAA (Retained Incident Sharing and Analysis Act) into the framework of Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA). This integration reflects a nuanced approach towards balancing national security imperatives with individual privacy rights, a dialogue increasingly relevant in today's digital age.

Section 702 and FISA
Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) differs from other surveillance authorities in several key ways: Intersection of Section 702, Net Neutrality, the Internet Bill of Rights, and the Patriot ActThe intersection of Section 702, Net Neutrality, the Internet Bill of Rights, and the Patriot Act presents a

Understanding Section 702

Section 702 authorizes the U.S. National Security Agency (NSA) to collect foreign intelligence information about non-U.S. persons located outside the United States. This section primarily targets foreign individuals suspected of terrorism, espionage, and other activities that may threaten national security. The collection of data is typically performed through electronic surveillance of international communications.

The FISA expansion turning cable installers into spies cannot stand
No democracy should give its government the Orwellian power contained in the House bill.

The Emergence of RISAA

The Retained Incident Sharing and Analysis Act (RISAA) was introduced to refine and enhance the data collection capabilities under Section 702. RISAA aims to establish a formal structure for sharing cybersecurity threat information between intelligence agencies and private entities. This is particularly important given the increasing sophistication of cyber threats and the need for rapid sharing of threat intelligence.

Key Features of RISAA
  1. Enhanced Data Retention: RISAA mandates the retention of certain types of communications that are deemed critical for analyzing and mitigating cybersecurity threats. This includes data from unsuccessful cyber-attack attempts, which can provide valuable insights for future threat prevention.
  2. Public-Private Collaboration: Under RISAA, there is a structured mechanism for intelligence agencies to share retained data with private cybersecurity firms. This collaboration is intended to enhance the overall cybersecurity posture by leveraging the specialized capabilities of private entities.
  3. Privacy Protections: RISAA incorporates stringent measures to safeguard the privacy of individuals. The act stipulates that data collected must be strictly used for cybersecurity purposes, with clear oversight and auditing mechanisms to prevent misuse.
  4. Transparency Reports: One of the standout features of RISAA is the requirement for periodic transparency reports. These reports detail the nature of data being collected and shared under the act, providing an additional layer of accountability.
Intersection of Section 702, Net Neutrality, the Internet Bill of Rights, and the Patriot Act
The intersection of Section 702, Net Neutrality, the Internet Bill of Rights, and the Patriot Act presents a complex landscape for digital privacy, security, and freedom. Each of these elements plays a distinct yet interconnected role in shaping the online experience and the protection of user data. Net Neutrality, Internet

Implications for Cybersecurity

The integration of RISAA into Section 702 represents a significant step towards creating a more resilient cybersecurity infrastructure. By facilitating the flow of information between government bodies and private sectors, RISAA helps in building a more robust defense against cyber threats. Moreover, the focus on privacy and transparency under RISAA helps in maintaining public trust, which is crucial for the successful implementation of any cybersecurity initiative.

Challenges Ahead

Despite its benefits, the implementation of RISAA within the framework of Section 702 poses several challenges:

  • Balancing Privacy and Security: Ensuring that enhanced surveillance capabilities do not infringe on individual privacy rights remains a delicate balance.
  • International Implications: The global nature of the internet means that actions taken under RISAA and Section 702 have international repercussions, potentially affecting global cybersecurity norms and international relations.

Warrantless Queries of U.S. Person Information

RISAA does not require the intelligence community to obtain a court order before querying Section 702 data for information about U.S. persons (Americans). Instead, it prohibits the FBI from conducting U.S. person queries "that are solely designed to find and extract evidence of criminal activity," with some exceptions.3 This is less restrictive than bills like the Government Surveillance Reform Act (GSRA), which would generally require a warrant for U.S. person queries.4

Expansion of Entities that Can Assist Surveillance

A concerning provision in RISAA is that it "dramatically expands the universe of entities that can be compelled to assist the government in conducting Section 702 surveillance."1 This could allow the government to use commercial landlords and other private entities as de facto surveillance agents, which critics argue poses a serious threat to civil liberties and democracy.1

Lack of Robust Reforms

While RISAA includes some reforms to Section 702, such as prohibiting certain FBI queries, critics argue that the bill "strongly resembles the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence (HPSCI) bill, which focuses more on expanding surveillance than reining it in."2 Groups like EPIC have called for more robust reforms, such as a warrant requirement for backdoor searches and closing the "data broker loophole."2


The incorporation of RISAA into Section 702 reflects an evolving cybersecurity strategy that recognizes the importance of intelligence sharing in combating cyber threats while also upholding the values of privacy and transparency. As cyber threats continue to evolve, such legislative frameworks will play a crucial role in shaping the future of global cybersecurity.

Read more